Matching Discontinued Siding: What Works When the Product Is Gone
By Bay Area Siding Company


Share —
When your siding is no longer made, you have four realistic options: borrow matching boards from a hidden part of the house, find or custom-mill a close match, re-side a full wall or elevation so any difference ends at a corner, or replace the siding on the whole house. Which one fits depends on how much is damaged, how visible it is, and whether the rest of the siding is worth keeping. If the damage is an insured loss, California regulations also require insurers on replacement-cost policies to restore a reasonably uniform appearance when the replacement pieces do not match.
Your options at a glance
| Option | Works best when | Trade-offs |
|---|---|---|
| Salvage from a hidden wall | Damage is small and a low-visibility wall (garage, behind a fence, side yard) has the same siding | The donor wall then needs a substitute product |
| Find a close current match | The profile is common (standard lap, bevel, shingle) | Thickness, texture or exposure may differ slightly; paint hides color but not shape |
| Custom mill | Wood siding with a distinctive profile, such as older redwood patterns | Lead time and setup cost; only practical for wood |
| Re-side one full elevation | Damage is concentrated on one side of the house | Different siding on different faces; works best ending at corners |
| Transition with trim | A change in material can be placed at a natural break, such as between floors | Changes the look; needs proper flashing at the joint |
| Replace all the siding | The old product is failing as a type, or matching is impossible | Highest up-front cost, but solves matching and hidden damage at once |
First, identify what you have
Before you can match siding, you need to know exactly what it is. Useful steps:
- Measure a board. Record the exposure (the visible height of each course), the total board width, the thickness at the bottom edge, and the profile shape (bevel, Dutch lap, shiplap, channel, beaded).
- Check the texture. Smooth, woodgrain embossed, rough-sawn or a specific pattern. Embossed grain patterns differ between manufacturers.
- Look at the back. When a damaged board comes off, the back often carries a manufacturer's stamp, product name or grade mark.
- Check records. Building permit records, original plans or a previous owner's paperwork sometimes name the product.
- Bring a sample. A short offcut taken to a supplier is the fastest way to compare profiles side by side.
On older homes, test before you cut. Some siding installed in the mid-20th century contains asbestos, and painted siding on homes built before 1978 may have lead paint. Our asbestos siding guide covers what that means for repairs.
Siding products you will no longer find new
Many products have been discontinued over the years, from individual colors and textures to whole product lines. A few common examples on Bay Area homes:
- Masonite hardboard siding. According to International Paper's 2002 annual report (Masonite's parent company at the time), Masonite stopped selling its hardboard siding in May 2001, after class-action settlements over hardboard and Omniwood siding. Our Masonite siding guide covers how to identify and replace it.
- LP Inner-Seal OSB siding. LP's earlier OSB siding was the subject of a nationwide class settlement approved in 1996. A 1997 review by BuildingGreen described LP's new Smart siding line as an evolution from Inner-Seal, with a changed binder and process. Inner-Seal itself is no longer sold.
- Asbestos-cement shingles and siding. These were used widely on mid-century homes and are not used in new construction today. Replacement shingles have to come from a different material, such as fiber cement shingles.
- Older colors and textures in current lines. Vinyl and fiber cement makers update colors, textures and profiles over time. A board from a current line may fit but not match a 15-year-old factory color or embossing pattern.
How each matching option works
Salvaging boards from a hidden wall
This is the oldest trick in siding repair and still one of the best for small damage. Original boards are carefully removed from a wall nobody sees, such as inside a garage bump-out, behind a fence or on a narrow side yard, and moved to the visible damaged area. The donor wall gets the closest current product. Because the original boards have the same profile and age, the repair blends once the wall is painted. It works only if there is enough siding on the donor wall and the boards come off without cracking.
Finding a close current match
Standard lap siding in common exposures is easy to match closely in wood, fiber cement and engineered wood. The details that give a patch away are thickness at the bottom edge (which changes the shadow line), the grain pattern, and the exposure. Mixing brands of fiber cement on the same wall is a common mistake; textures and widths are close but not identical, as we explain in our Allura vs Hardie comparison.
Custom milling
Wood siding profiles can be reproduced by a mill that cuts new knives to match a sample. This is how many older redwood and cedar profiles on Victorians, Craftsman homes and early 20th-century houses are matched. It is practical for wood only. Manufactured products such as hardboard, vinyl and fiber cement cannot be custom-made in small quantities.
Re-siding one elevation
If damage is concentrated on one side of the house, re-siding that entire wall with a current product means any difference in texture or profile sits around a corner from the original, where the eye does not compare them directly. With the whole house painted the same color, this often reads as intentional. It also lets the weather barrier and window flashing on that wall be rebuilt.
Transitions with trim
A horizontal trim band, such as a belly band between the first and second floor, can separate two different sidings cleanly. Mixed exteriors, such as lap siding below and shingles or board and batten above, are a common design choice anyway. Every horizontal transition needs a Z-flashing or similar detail so water running down the upper wall is kicked out over the lower siding.
Insurance and matching
When siding is damaged by a covered event, matching becomes an insurance question. California's Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations, at 10 CCR 2695.9(a)(2), say that when a replacement-cost policy covers a loss that requires replacement of items and the replaced items do not match in quality, color or size, the insurer shall replace all items in the damaged area so as to conform to a reasonably uniform appearance.
The regulation does not define "the damaged area," and that is where most disputes happen: whether it means the damaged boards, the damaged wall, or every wall that would look mismatched. Practical steps:
- Document that the product is discontinued, with supplier statements or manufacturer information.
- Photograph how a patch with the closest available product would look next to the original.
- Ask your contractor for a written explanation of why a uniform appearance requires the wider scope.
- Read your policy's matching language, since some policies have endorsements that limit it.
Our guide to siding damage and homeowners insurance covers the claims process in more detail.
When full replacement is the better answer
Sometimes the discontinued product is the real problem. Hardboard and older OSB siding that is already swelling at the bottom edges will keep failing, and spending money matching it rarely makes sense. Full replacement is worth considering when:
- The original product is failing on more than one wall
- Repairs would need patches on several elevations
- The weather barrier and flashing behind the siding are also at the end of their life
- You are planning to repaint or replace windows anyway
Our guide to siding repair vs replacement walks through that decision, and our siding replacement page explains what a full re-side includes.
Frequently asked questions
How do I find out what siding I have?
Measure the exposure, thickness and profile, note the texture, and check the back of a removed board for a manufacturer's stamp. Permit records and original plans can also help. Taking a short sample to a supplier is the fastest way to compare.
Can discontinued siding be matched?
Often closely, rarely perfectly. Common lap profiles have close current equivalents, wood profiles can be custom-milled, and boards can be salvaged from hidden walls. Manufactured products with distinctive textures or factory colors are the hardest to match.
Does insurance have to replace all my siding if it can't be matched?
Not necessarily all of it. In California, insurers on replacement-cost policies must replace items in the damaged area so they have a reasonably uniform appearance when replacements do not match. How far "the damaged area" extends is often negotiated, so document the mismatch and the product's discontinued status.
Can I mix two siding brands on one wall?
It is not recommended. Even similar products differ in thickness, texture and width, and the difference shows when they sit side by side. Changing materials at a corner or a trim band looks far better.
Is Masonite siding still made?
No. According to International Paper's 2002 annual report, Masonite stopped selling its hardboard siding in May 2001. Repairs today use salvaged boards or a different product, and many homeowners choose to replace it.
Sources
The information provided here is intended for general reference and should not be considered professional advice. Before starting any project, consult a licensed contractor. Product features, specifications, and warranties may have been updated since this was published. Any mention of brands or products reflects personal opinion and does not constitute an endorsement or warranty.












