Cedar and redwood are the two classic wood sidings on Bay Area houses, and both last for decades when they are detailed well and refinished on schedule. Their heartwood resists decay naturally, they take stain or paint well, and nothing else looks quite the same. The trade-offs are regular maintenance and fire: untreated cedar and redwood are combustible, so on a lot in a Fire Hazard Severity Zone they have to be fire-retardant treated for exterior use or installed as part of a wall assembly that meets California's wildfire-zone rules. Fiber cement and engineered wood products with cedar textures are the usual alternatives.
Types of cedar and redwood siding
| Type | What it looks like | Where you see it | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bevel (clapboard) siding | Horizontal boards, thicker at the bottom edge, each overlapping the one below | Craftsman, Victorian and traditional homes | The most common wood lap profile; easy to repair board by board |
| Shingles and shakes | Individual tapered pieces in overlapping courses; shingles are sawn, shakes are split and rougher | Brown-shingle and Craftsman houses, gables, coastal homes | Lots of edges to weather; usually left natural or stained |
| Board and batten | Wide vertical boards with narrow battens over the joints | Rustic, farmhouse and mid-century homes | Vertical boards shed water well; batten edges need upkeep |
| Tongue-and-groove and channel | Boards that interlock edge to edge, laid flat or with a shadow channel | Mid-century modern and contemporary homes | Clean look; joints must stay tight and painted or sealed |
For more on shingle and shake patterns, see our shake siding guide.
Redwood on Bay Area homes
Redwood is common on older Bay Area houses, both as lap siding and shingles on early twentieth-century homes and as vertical boards on many mid-century houses. Natural decay resistance is in the heartwood only; the lighter sapwood near the bark has little. Redwood on older houses often came from old-growth trees, and studies have found old-growth redwood heartwood to be more decay-resistant, on average, than heartwood from younger trees. That helps explain why some 80-year-old redwood siding is still sound, while new boards need more careful detailing and finishing.
If your house still has original redwood in good shape, repairing and refinishing it is often worth doing. Matching old-growth boards is difficult with new lumber, so salvaging boards from less visible walls to patch the front is a common approach.
Cedar vs redwood
- Western red cedar is light, stable and takes stain well. It is widely available as bevel siding, shingles and tongue-and-groove, and it is the usual choice for new wood siding.
- Redwood has a deeper red color and is also stable and decay-resistant in the heartwood. Clear heart grades are expensive and supply varies, so redwood is now more common in repairs and high-end work than in whole-house re-siding.
- Grades matter more than species. Clear, vertical-grain heartwood holds finish and resists cupping far better than knotty or sapwood-rich boards of either species.
Maintenance and lifespan
Wood siding lasts as long as its finish and its water details hold up. Neglected wood fails at the same spots every time: bottom edges near soil or decks, end grain at butt joints and corners, under windows, and where roofs meet walls.
- Finish choice: clear finishes and semi-transparent stains show the grain but need recoating more often. Solid stains and paint protect longer but hide the wood.
- Climate: foggy, shaded walls near the coast grow mildew and stay damp; sunny south and west walls inland weather and gray fastest. Expect different recoat schedules on different sides of the same house.
- Details: keep siding off soil and concrete, flash horizontal joints and window heads, and seal end grain at every cut.
- Fasteners: use corrosion-resistant nails; ordinary steel nails stain cedar and redwood with black streaks.
Our guide to preventing dry rot covers inspection and repair in more detail.
Fire-zone limits in California
Untreated cedar and redwood are combustible. California's wildfire-zone building rules accept an exterior wall if it meets one of these paths:
- The wall covering is noncombustible or ignition-resistant material.
- The wall is heavy timber or log construction.
- The wall assembly passes a 10-minute flame exposure test under the State Fire Marshal's standard.
For wood, that means one of two things. The University of California's fire advisors note that the most common ignition-resistant material is exterior-rated, fire-retardant-treated wood, which is pressure treated at the mill and labeled for exterior use. Alternatively, horizontal lap wood siding usually complies through the third path, by using plywood or OSB sheathing (or other tested layers) behind it as part of a tested assembly. California's code also states that paints, coatings, stains and other surface treatments are not an approved method of protection, so a fire-retardant coating brushed onto ordinary siding does not count.
UC's guidance also recommends noncombustible or ignition-resistant siding for homes within 30 feet of a neighboring house. If your lot is in Marin, the Oakland or Berkeley hills, or another mapped hazard zone, confirm the compliance path with your building department before ordering wood. Our fire-resistant siding guide covers vents, eaves and the other parts of a fire-resistant exterior.
Alternatives with a wood look
Fiber cement
James Hardie makes HardiePlank lap siding in a Select Cedarmill texture with a soft cedar grain, HardieShingle in straight-edge and staggered-edge panels, and HardiePanel vertical siding including the grooved Sierra 8 texture. Fiber cement is noncombustible when tested to ASTM E136, doesn't rot, and holds paint longer than wood. It won't take a transparent stain, so the look is painted wood rather than natural grain. See our Mill Valley HardieShingle project for a shingle example.
Engineered wood
LP SmartSide comes in a cedar texture in lap, panel and shake profiles. It is lighter than fiber cement, cuts like wood and is treated against decay and termites, with a 5/50-year limited warranty on its lap and panel lines. It is combustible, so check your fire hazard zone. Our LP SmartSide review has the details.
How to choose
- Keep or repair real wood if you have sound original redwood or cedar, the house's character depends on it, and you are willing to refinish on a schedule.
- Use new cedar for a natural, stained look outside fire hazard zones, or with an approved fire-retardant-treated product or tested assembly inside them.
- Choose fiber cement if you want a painted wood look with less upkeep and a noncombustible wall.
- Mix materials: fiber cement on the main walls with real wood at an entry or accent wall is a common compromise.
Our wood siding page explains how we repair and install cedar and redwood, and we give a free written estimate after a walkthrough.
Frequently asked questions
Is cedar or redwood better for siding?
Both are stable and naturally decay-resistant in the heartwood. Cedar is easier to find in common siding profiles and is the usual choice for new work. Redwood is often used for repairs to match existing Bay Area homes.
How long does cedar siding last?
With good detailing and regular refinishing, cedar and redwood siding last for decades. Without maintenance, bottom edges, end grain and areas under windows can rot within a few years.
Can you use cedar siding in a California fire zone?
Untreated cedar is combustible. In a Fire Hazard Severity Zone, wood siding generally has to be exterior fire-retardant-treated wood or part of a wall assembly that passes the State Fire Marshal's test, usually with specific sheathing behind it. Paints, stains and surface coatings don't qualify.
Should cedar siding be painted or stained?
Either works. Semi-transparent stains and clear finishes show the grain but need recoating more often. Solid stains and paint protect longer and hide variation in the wood.
What siding looks like cedar but needs less maintenance?
Fiber cement in cedar textures, such as HardiePlank Select Cedarmill and HardieShingle, and engineered wood such as LP SmartSide in cedar texture. Fiber cement is also noncombustible.
Sources
The information provided here is intended for general reference and should not be considered professional advice. Before starting any project, consult a licensed contractor. Product features, specifications, and warranties may have been updated since this was published. Any mention of brands or products reflects personal opinion and does not constitute an endorsement or warranty.














